Whisper MoneyW
Whisper Money
May 26

Have a way to manage return transactions so they reduce expense

Let's say I have paid a meal with my friends. I paid the 100€ bill. We split the bill so each of my friends pay me back 20€ in 4 different transactions. I would have these transactions in the app: * Meal payment: -100€ * Person 1 return: +20€ * Person 2 return: +20€ * Person 3 return: +20€ * Person 4 return: +20€ This will create a cash flow with 80€ of income and 100€ of expense, when it should have just been 20€ of expense. The same happens with purchase returns. Let's say I pay 30€ for something, and after returning it, they give me back my 30€ in another transaction. I would have a cash flow of 30€ of income and 30€ of expense, when it should be 0 of both. The easiest solution that came to my mind would be to consider positive transactions when they are categorized as expense. For example, in the first situation, I could set all transactions as "Meals". The cash flow should consider that if I have +80 and -100, the actual expense of Meals during that month is -20. This is the actual solution that came to my mind as the easier one, but feel free to propose others! Happy to help in the development of it if needed 😄
ClosedClosed

May 27, 2026

Closed, because it's a bug not a feature request. Anyway, I’ll let you know here once the fix is deployed.

May 27, 2026

Víctor Falcón great! Thanks! Let me know if I can give a hand!

May 27, 2026

@corderop: must be fixed now ;)

May 30, 2026

Víctor Falcón Amazing! 🙌�

May 27, 2026

Doing this right now is possible. If you assign those 5 transactions to the same category, for example restaurant. In the cashflow page you will see that you have spent 20€ on restaurants.

May 27, 2026

Víctor Falcón Not my experience in the version 0.2.3 version, but if it's considered a bug, we can continue in a github issue:

May 27, 2026

Víctor Falcón It's like that in some part it says 20 and in other places it says 100

May 27, 2026

@corderop: Yes, definitely it's a bug. I will fix it ;)

May 26, 2026

In my case, this is important because it allows you to see, first, the real amounts that you spend per category, and second the real incomes numbers and sources